Down 20%? 40%? 60%? Let Me Share What Each of Those Numbers Mean

Hey there, fellow Etsy entrepreneur! If you’ve ever stared at your sales numbers with a furrowed brow, wondering why your shop suddenly feels like it’s caught in a slow slide, you’re not alone. The truth is, drops in sales happen to the best of us, and understanding what those dips really mean can be the difference between panic and power moves.

Today, I’m going to break down what it means when your Etsy shop is down 20%, 40%, or even 60%. We’ll walk through how to interpret these numbers, what’s likely behind them, and what you can do to get back on track. So grab your coffee (or wine, no judgment here) and let’s dive in.

Getting Friendly With Your Numbers: The First Step to Growth

Before we start diagnosing drops and plotting comebacks, the very first thing you’ve got to do is build a healthy relationship with your numbers. I get it—numbers can feel like the villain in your story. But trust me, when you remove the emotion and look at them as just numbers (not money), you take away a lot of the sting.

Here’s a quick example: Imagine you usually make about $3,000 a month on Etsy. Then, Valentine’s Day rolls around, and you hit $5,000. Woohoo! But the next month, you drop back to $2,400. Panic sets in—“I’m down! My business is dying!”

But wait a second. You’re actually still above your usual $3,000 monthly average—that Valentine’s Day spike was a seasonal peak, not your baseline. The mistake a lot of us make is setting our baseline from the peak instead of the norm. It’s like expecting to run a marathon at your fastest sprint pace—unsustainable and setting yourself up for disappointment.

Lesson #1: Your Etsy income isn’t a paycheck

Unlike a steady paycheck, your Etsy earnings ebb and flow. Your paycheck doesn’t have a ceiling, but it also doesn’t come in a predictable amount. Some months you’ll hustle hard and see results, other months not so much. And that’s okay—it’s part of the entrepreneurial rollercoaster.

Also, beware of the year-over-year trap. Comparing this February to last February might seem logical, but if last year you launched a killer product or had a viral moment, it’s unrealistic to expect the same spike every year without fresh effort. Entrepreneurship is risk and hustle, not autopilot.

How to Look at Your Etsy Shop’s Performance: Monthly? Quarterly? Yearly?

I don’t love obsessing over month-to-month numbers because they can be noisy. Instead, I recommend looking at your data quarterly and then year-over-year by quarter. This gives you a bigger picture and smooths out the wild swings.

For example, if you see a $5,000 month followed by a $2,800 month and then a $3,000 month, that’s actually pretty normal. The $3,000 is your baseline, and the $5,000 was a seasonal spike. So why panic over the dip?

Also, track not just your sales but your work ethic. Are you building your shop, adding listings, tweaking keywords? Or are you just fulfilling orders and hoping for the best? Those two are very different mindsets and will show up in your numbers.

What Does a 20% Drop Mean? Welcome to the Competition Zone

If your sales have dipped about 20-25%, the first thing to suspect is competition. Etsy is a marketplace full of hustlers, and if your product category has suddenly gotten crowded, it’s going to impact your clicks and sales.

Here’s what usually happens: You find a niche or product that’s working well. You start making sales. Then, other sellers notice and jump in, flooding the market with similar items. Suddenly, your once-blue ocean turns choppy.

When you see a 20% drop, it’s time to get your detective hat on. Search for your products and see who’s showing up. Are they cheaper? Are they offering different styles or bundles? Are they copying your designs? This is just part of the game on Etsy—competition is expected, and it’s not personal.

Pro Tip: Don’t curse the heavens or get mad. Instead, accept that your shop listings are product-based, not your entire store. It’s usually certain products that are under attack, dragging your overall revenue down. Plan for this and be ready to pivot.

40% Drop: Is This Etsy’s Fault or Something Else?

Now, when you’re staring at a 40% drop, things get a bit more serious. This could be due to multiple factors including Etsy’s algorithm changes, a drop in traffic, or a waning interest in your product category.

Remember in October last year when Etsy updated their search algorithm? Many sellers lost traffic because Etsy stopped showing multiple listings from the same shop on front-page search results. If your shop relied heavily on variants or similar products, this could explain a big dip.

But beyond Etsy’s changes, ask yourself:

• Has my conversion rate dropped?

• Has my traffic decreased?

• Is the demand for my product still there?

If your traffic drops about 40%, that’s actually a logical cause for a 40% drop in sales. It means your front-end traffic problem is the main culprit. Your job? Drive more traffic through SEO, ads, social media, or whatever channels work for you.

But here’s the kicker: Sometimes the problem isn’t Etsy or traffic at all—it’s the product itself. Trends come and go. Maybe you were selling dinosaur nursery décor during its heyday, but now people are onto the next big thing.

Trend cycles on Etsy tend to lag about six months to a year behind platforms like Pinterest or Instagram. If you’re still holding onto last year’s “it” product, it’s time to pivot.

How to Spot a Trend’s Rise and Fall

I’ve been there. Remember the chevron stripe craze? I was ahead of the curve, stocked up, and selling rolls of fabric like hotcakes. But six months later, sales dropped because everyone else caught on and the market became saturated.

The lesson? Be the trendsetter, not the last one holding onto last season’s hot item. Keep your finger on the pulse of emerging trends and be ready to evolve.

60% or More Drop: Pricing and Product Value Are Your Biggest Foes

If you’re seeing a massive drop—like 50% or 60%—it usually means you’re fighting a combination of all the issues mentioned above plus pricing challenges.

Here’s the harsh truth: If your competitors are selling similar products cheaper and doing a better job marketing, you’re going to lose sales. Etsy buyers are savvy and often price-sensitive. If you’re charging more, you better be delivering more in terms of quality, branding, or customer experience.

Want to be the “BMW” of your niche? That’s a great goal! But remember, most Etsy shoppers are bargain hunters or DIY enthusiasts. You have to earn your premium pricing by building trust, getting glowing reviews, and showing why your product is worth every penny.

How to Compete When Price Is a Factor

1. Improve your product photography:

   Take multiple photos showcasing different moods and styles—bright and happy, classic and clean, modern flat lays.

2. Build social proof:

   Encourage reviews, share customer testimonials, and show your product in real-life use.

3. Offer bundles or add-ons:

   Give buyers more value for their money.

4. Focus on keywords and SEO:

   Diversify your listings’ keywords to capture broader traffic.

5. Consider targeted advertising:

   Use Etsy ads or social media ads to reach your ideal customers.

Keep Your Etsy Shop Alive: The Power of Consistent Updates

If you’re consistently seeing drops in sales, it might be time to take a hard look at your shop maintenance. Often, when shops start to slow down, sellers get complacent—they stop adding new listings, stop updating photos, and just focus on fulfilling orders.

Think of your shop like a garden. You can’t just plant seeds, harvest once, and expect it to keep flourishing without more planting and care. If you’ve been in a “harvest” phase where you’re just fulfilling orders, it’s time to jump back into “planting” mode.

Here’s a simple checklist to refresh your shop:

• Add new listings regularly.

• Update product photos with fresh, varied styles.

• Experiment with new keywords and themes.

• Remove or overhaul listings that aren’t performing.

• Engage with your customers and encourage repeat business.

Remember, Etsy’s algorithm likes fresh content. If you keep the same listings with the same photos for months, Etsy will start shuffling your products off the front page. Keep things fresh and give Etsy reasons to show your shop to buyers.

Why Multiple Photos Matter

Think about running Facebook ads: Facebook tests which ad performs best and then spends more money there until ad fatigue sets in. Etsy doesn’t have that fancy ad algorithm, but it does shuffle what it shows buyers. If you only have one style of product photo, Etsy will eventually move you off the front page in favor of fresher, more engaging listings.

Take multiple photos with different moods and styles. Bright and cheerful, minimalist and clean, lifestyle shots, flat lays—you name it. This variety can breathe new life into your listings and attract different types of buyers.

Final Thoughts: Don’t Panic, Plan

So, what do these numbers really mean? Here’s a quick recap:

• Down 20%?

  Likely competition. Time to scout the market and plan your next move.

• Down 40%?

  Could be Etsy changes, a drop in traffic, or fading demand. Check your traffic and conversion rates, then refresh your shop.

• Down 60% or more?

  Probably a mix of competition, pricing issues, and product relevance. Time to rethink pricing, marketing, and maybe even your product line.

Remember, drops are normal in entrepreneurship. The key is how you respond. Stay curious, keep experimenting, and treat Etsy as your partner, not your enemy. You’re in control of your shop’s destiny.

Keep planting, keep hustling, and watch your Etsy shop grow.

Work with me!

I offer one on one coaching