Part 2 - Transactional Relationship: What Won My Money on Etsy

Welcome to another deep dive into the world of Etsy shopping and selling, where I share my personal journey of buying 10 products from different Etsy shops and unpack what really made me pull the trigger. In this installment, we're zooming in on the receiving experience—because, let's be honest, the magic doesn't stop when you click "buy." How you receive your product, how the seller treats you post-purchase, and how reviews are handled all play a massive role in whether you become a loyal customer or just a one-time passerby.

From Shopper to Buyer: The Gap Between Interest and Trust

Last week, I shared some initial thoughts on what caught my eye while browsing Etsy. As much as I’m immersed in the Etsy universe, buying a handful of times a year, this time I approached it like a detective. I wasn’t just buying; I was analyzing every detail—from product photos to descriptions, to how shops presented their offers.

One huge takeaway was how quickly I lost trust when questions went unanswered. If a product listing left me hanging, I bounced. I also found myself hunting for customer photos outside the shop’s own pictures, because let’s face it, product photos taken by the sellers can sometimes be too perfect or staged. Seeing how real customers showcased the product gave me confidence.

Why Trust is Everything

Think about it—shopping online, especially on platforms like Etsy, is a leap of faith. You’re handing over your hard-earned cash for something you can’t touch or try beforehand. If there’s any doubt, hesitation, or unanswered questions, you’re likely to abandon cart faster than you can say “free shipping.”

One shop I connected with had a pretty sweet offer: “Become a VIP and get 50% off your order plus exclusive free prints.” Sounds great, right? Well, not quite. The phrase “Become a VIP” didn’t speak to me. I’m not looking to join a club—I just want the discount and freebies! The messaging felt like a wall instead of a welcome mat.

How to Speak Your Customer’s Language: The Power of Clear Offers

Messaging matters. Instead of “Become a VIP,” what if the sign said:

• “Get 50% off this order instantly!”
• “Scan this QR code to claim your discount plus 4 additional free prints.”

Now, that’s an offer I can’t ignore. It tells me exactly what I’m getting and why it’s worth my time. It invites me in instead of making me guess what “VIP” means. The key here is to convince the customer why they should take action, rather than just telling them to do something.

It’s the same principle that makes some book titles grab your attention while others get ignored. Your offer has to speak directly to your buyer’s desires and needs.

The Review Request Nightmare: Etsy’s Heavy Handed Approach

Okay, let me vent for a sec because this one really grinds my gears. After buying 10 products, I got bombarded with review requests from Etsy. I mean, it felt like I was their employee, not a customer. Notifications popping up left and right—“You still have 4 products to review!” Dude, I get it, but chill.

Here’s the thing: online behavior is the worst version of ourselves. We have zero patience, and anything annoying or pushy makes us want to flee. Etsy’s current review system feels like a nagging boss rather than a friendly nudge.

What would work better? Imagine Etsy asking:

1. “Hey, we have three quick questions about your recent purchase. Can you spare 15 seconds?”
2. “Did your order arrive on time?”
3. “Was the product as expected?”
4. “Want to add any photos or extra feedback?”

Simple, conversational, and engaging. Plus, offer a tiny incentive—like a 25-cent credit for every photo review left. That would actually motivate shoppers to share their thoughts and pictures, which in turn builds trust for future buyers.

Why Reviews Matter More Than Ever

Reviews are the lifeblood of Etsy shops. But here’s a reality check: fulfilling your end of the bargain (shipping the product as promised) isn’t enough to earn glowing reviews. It’s a transactional contract—like buying a Big Mac at McDonald’s and expecting a five-star Yelp review just because it tasted like a Big Mac.

To truly win over customers, you have to go beyond the transaction.

The Secret Sauce: Creating Memorable Experiences

Ask yourself these questions:

• Do you want your customers to be excited when they receive your product?

• Do you want them to remember you and tell their friends?

• Do you want them to come back for more?

If you answered yes (and you should), then you need to deliver more value than just the product itself. Whether it’s a personalized touch, a surprise bonus, or exceptional packaging, these little things make a huge difference.

The Hash Brown Effect: Small Extras That Build Loyalty

Here’s a fun analogy: imagine going through a McDonald’s drive-thru, getting your Big Mac, and opening the box to find a free hash brown you didn’t order. You didn’t pay for it, you didn’t ask for it, but suddenly you’re thinking, “Wow, that was nice!”

Even if you suspect it was a happy accident, that small gesture creates a positive memory. You’re more likely to remember that particular McDonald’s and maybe even prefer it next time.

In Etsy terms, what’s your hash brown? A handwritten thank-you note, a free sticker, a sample, or a little extra product bundled in? These surprises create a warm fuzzy feeling that can turn a one-time buyer into a loyal fan.

A Real-Life Story: The Power of Kindness and Connection

Let me share a story from my own life that illustrates this perfectly. Recently, my son traded a Pokémon card worth hundreds of dollars. We took it to a card shop, and while he was selling it, another kid (my middle son) was feeling left out and started to tear up. A kind stranger noticed and gave him a free Pokémon pack—worth about $7.

My son was touched and a bit overwhelmed by the generosity. It was a small act but made a huge impact on him. It even inspired him to “pay it forward” by buying some cards back from that stranger later on. This exchange wasn’t about money—it was about kindness and connection.

That’s exactly the kind of feeling you want to foster with your Etsy customers. Make them feel special, valued, and part of something bigger.

How to Build a Relationship That Encourages Reviews

If you want to increase your review rate and build lasting relationships, it starts with communication. Here’s a simple step-by-step approach you can try:

1. Send a friendly pre-shipment message:

   “Hey, we’re excited to start making your order! Here are some FAQs you might find helpful.”

2. Notify when shipped:

   “Your order is on its way! Let me know if you have any questions.”

3. Follow up post-delivery:

   “Hope you love your purchase! If you have any feedback or want to share photos, I’d love to see them.”

4. Make leaving a review easy and rewarding:

   Include a little card in the package explaining how to leave a review and maybe offer a small future discount or freebie for doing so.

Yes, this takes time and effort, especially if you’re running a busy shop, but the payoff can be huge. Even one customer remembering you because of your thoughtful communication is worth it.

Systematizing Without Losing the Human Touch

If you’re overwhelmed with orders, consider automating parts of this process with personalized templates or apps—but don’t lose the warmth. Your customers want to feel like they’re dealing with a person, not a robot.

Boosting Perceived Value: More Than Just the Product

The packaging moment is golden. When your customer opens your product, they’re fully engaged. This is your chance to shine:

• Include a heartfelt thank-you note explaining how their purchase supports your dream.

• Show a behind-the-scenes photo of your workshop or team.

• Add a curated list of tips, freebies, or complementary products.

• Throw in a small surprise gift or sticker.

Even if the extra doesn’t cost much, it boosts the perceived value of the purchase. It’s not just a product—it’s an experience.

The Ultimate Goal: Making Your Customers Feel Good

When Etsy sends out those annoying review reminders, your customers might be thinking, “I don’t owe anyone anything.” And honestly, they don’t. But what if you’ve already made them feel like they want to leave a review because you made their day better?

That’s the difference between a transactional sale and a memorable experience. You’re not just exchanging money for a product; you’re building a relationship.

Remember:

• People remember kindness and surprises.

• Clear, compelling messaging wins hearts and wallets.

• Thoughtful communication creates trust and loyalty.

• Reviews are earned, not demanded.

Final Thoughts

If you’ve made it this far, you’re already ahead of many Etsy sellers who overlook the post-purchase experience. Remember, getting a sale is tough, but keeping a customer and turning them into a raving fan is where the real magic happens.

So, take a moment to rethink how you communicate your offers, how you package your products, and how you follow up after the sale. Small changes—like rewording an offer or including a little freebie—can transform your shop from just another listing to a beloved brand.

Go ahead, make your customers feel good. It’s the best investment you’ll ever make.

Till next time, happy selling and thank you for supporting small businesses!

Work with me!

I offer one on one coaching