One Pricing Trick That Boosts Sales: Anchoring Explained

If you’ve ever wondered how some sellers manage to charge more and still make more sales, you’re about to uncover one of the best-kept secrets in pricing strategy: price anchoring. This simple yet powerful psychological trick can transform how customers perceive your prices, making your best offers look like irresistible deals—even if they’re higher than what you might expect them to pay.

Whether you’re selling handmade crafts, printables, custom gifts, or anything in between on Etsy, understanding price anchoring can seriously boost your sales and help you get paid what you’re worth. Let’s dive into what price anchoring is, how it works, and practical ways you can use it right now to maximize your Etsy shop’s profitability.

What Is Price Anchoring?

Imagine walking into a bar and seeing their beer menu. If the first beer you see costs $2, that sets a certain expectation. But what if the first beer listed is $10? Suddenly, the $2 beer looks like a bargain. That’s the essence of price anchoring—presenting a higher-priced option first so that everything that follows seems more affordable.

This isn’t just theory. There was an actual study at a bar in Ireland where they experimented with the order of beer prices on their menu. For three months, they listed the cheapest beers at the top and the priciest at the bottom, resulting in an average order price of about $4. Then, they flipped the order, putting the $10 beers at the top and the $2 beers at the bottom. The average order price jumped to $6. That’s a whopping 50% increase in what customers were willing to spend, all because of how the prices were presented.

So, price anchoring is about setting a mental benchmark—a price anchor—that influences how customers view the rest of your pricing. It’s a subtle nudge that shifts their expectations and makes your mid-tier or even premium offerings feel like a smart, affordable choice.

The Psychology Behind Price Anchoring

Why does this work? It’s all about human psychology and how our brains process value and price comparisons. When a customer sees a high price first, their brain sets that as the “anchor.” Every other price is then compared to that anchor, making lower prices seem more reasonable—even if they’re still on the higher side.

Here’s a quick example from everyday life to illustrate this: Say you’re selling a service with three pricing options. If you start by saying, “The full package is $500,” then offer a mid-tier package at $150, suddenly $150 looks like a steal compared to $500. But if you start at $6 and work your way up to $150, $150 might seem steep.

My dad, a seasoned salesman, shared a classic sales tactic that perfectly demonstrates this. When clients asked about advertising costs in his wedding magazine business, he would say, “It’s not going to be $5,000, don’t worry.” Then, after a solid pitch, he’d drop the price to $800. Compared to $5,000, $800 felt like a bargain, and clients were more likely to say yes. This is price anchoring in action—setting a high anchor to make the real price feel more attractive.

How to Use Price Anchoring in Your Etsy Shop

Now that you get the idea of price anchoring, let’s talk about some practical ways to apply it in your Etsy shop to boost sales and increase your average order value.

1. Present Your Highest-Priced Options First

When you list multiple pricing options for your product or service, start by showing the highest price first. This might mean creating bundles or packages where the most comprehensive option is listed at the top, followed by more basic or smaller options.

For example, if you sell custom prints, you could offer:

• Five-print bundle for $50

• Three-print bundle for $35

• Single print for $15

By showing the $50 bundle first, the $35 and $15 options feel more affordable and attractive, increasing the chances that customers will choose the mid-tier or even the premium package because it feels like a great deal compared to the highest-priced option.

2. Use Clear Pricing and Show Value Per Unit

When you create bundles, make sure it’s easy for customers to understand the cost per item. Confusing pricing creates friction and makes it harder for people to make a confident decision. For instance, don’t price two candles at $16 and four candles at $15—your customers will scratch their heads trying to figure out the deal.

Instead, keep it simple and transparent, like:

• One candle for $8

• Two candles for $15 ($7.50 each)

• Four candles for $28 ($7 each)

When customers can quickly see the savings per unit, they feel smarter about their purchase and are more likely to buy more.

3. Limit Your Options to Four Maximum

Here’s a quick but important tangent: The paradox of choice is real. The more options you give customers, the harder it is for them to decide. You want to avoid overwhelming them with too many choices.

Research shows that four options are the sweet spot. Any more than that, and decision fatigue kicks in, which can result in customers abandoning their purchase or feeling buyer’s remorse.

So, stick to four well-crafted options. For example, if you sell dog tags, offer four color or style choices. If you sell prints, have four bundle sizes. This keeps things manageable and helps customers feel confident they’re making the right choice.

4. Use Social Proof to Highlight Popular Choices

After you’ve set your pricing options and anchored your prices, add a little social proof by labeling your most popular option. Something as simple as “Most Popular” next to the mid-tier package can nudge customers to pick that option, following the crowd rather than agonizing over the decision.

Bonus Pricing Hacks to Make Your Prices Feel Smaller

Price anchoring is just one part of the pricing puzzle. Here are some quick additional tips to make your prices psychologically easier to swallow:

• Remove commas from prices:

  If you’re selling products in the thousands, take out the commas. For example, write 1500 instead of 1,500. It makes the price look less intimidating.

• Avoid currency symbols:

  Try listing prices without dollar signs or other currency symbols. High-end restaurants do this on their menus because it reduces the mental “ouch” factor.

• Use smaller fonts for prices:

  When prices are visually smaller, they feel less aggressive. This subtle design choice can encourage customers to focus more on the product than the cost.

• Use descriptive words carefully:

  Words like “low” and “small” can make prices feel less intimidating, while “high” or “big” can make them feel more expensive. For example, “low friction skates” sold better than “high-performance skates” at the same price because “low” feels easier on the wallet.

Putting It All Together: A Step-by-Step Guide to Price Anchoring

Let’s recap with a simple step-by-step process you can follow to use price anchoring in your Etsy shop:

1. Identify your pricing tiers:

   Create 3-4 pricing options or bundles, ranging from basic to premium.

2. Order your options strategically:

   Present the highest-priced option first, then work your way down.

3. Make the value clear:

   Show the cost per unit or per item to help customers quickly see the deal.

4. Limit your choices:

   Stick to four options max to avoid overwhelming buyers.

5. Add social proof:

   Label your best-selling or most popular option to guide indecisive customers.

6. Design your pricing display:

   Remove currency symbols, commas, and use small fonts to make prices feel less intimidating.

Why Price Anchoring Works for Etsy Sellers

As an Etsy seller, you’re competing not just on quality but also on perceived value. Price anchoring helps you control the narrative around your pricing and guides customers toward the options that are best for your business.

Instead of customers seeing your prices as arbitrary numbers, they become part of a carefully crafted story where your mid-tier or premium offerings shine as smart, affordable choices. This not only helps you increase your average order value but also builds trust and confidence in your customers’ buying decisions.

Final Thoughts

Price anchoring is one of those pricing tricks that sounds too simple to be true, but the results speak for themselves. From the Irish bar study to my dad’s sales stories, this technique has been proven time and again to boost sales and make higher prices feel more acceptable.

If you’ve been struggling with pricing your Etsy products or feeling like you’re leaving money on the table, try flipping your price presentation and watch how your customers respond. Pair that with clear options, social proof, and smart design choices, and you’ll be well on your way to selling more and earning more.

So go ahead, anchor your prices like a pro, and watch your Etsy shop thrive!

What’s your price anchor? Have you been using this trick without realizing it? Drop a comment below and share your experiences—I’d love to hear how price anchoring has worked for you!

Work with me!

I offer one on one coaching